[Medium] [Bug] [Spec-Inconsistency] Room type frequencies: spire-climbing-spec vs GAME_BRIEFING disagree on Swarm/Speed/Puzzle percentages #272

New Issue

2026-06-05T02:08:28+02:00

Anexim commented

2026-06-05 02:08:28 +02:00

Type: Spec / Spec inconsistency
Priority: Medium

spire-climbing-spec.md §4.3 defines room type frequencies:

Type	Frequency
combat	~68%
swarm	~12% (0.12)
speed	~10% (0.10)
guardian	Every 10th floor
recovery	~4%
treasure	~3%
library	~3%
puzzle	~1 per 7 floors

GAME_BRIEFING.md §Spire & Floor System says:

Room Type	Chance
Guardian	Every 10th floor
Puzzle	20% on every 7th floor
Swarm	15%
Speed	10%
Combat	Default

Discrepancies:

Swarm: spire-climbing-spec says ~12%, GAME_BRIEFING says 15%
Puzzle: spire-climbing-spec says "1 room per 7th floor" (deterministic), GAME_BRIEFING says "20% on every 7th floor" (probabilistic)
spire-climbing-spec has recovery/treasure/library rooms (~10% total) which GAME_BRIEFING doesn't mention at all

Recommendation: Reconcile room type definitions. The spire-climbing-spec is more detailed and includes non-combat rooms that GAME_BRIEFING omits entirely.

**Type:** Spec / Spec inconsistency **Priority:** Medium **spire-climbing-spec.md §4.3** defines room type frequencies: | Type | Frequency | |------|-----------| | combat | ~68% | | swarm | ~12% (0.12) | | speed | ~10% (0.10) | | guardian | Every 10th floor | | recovery | ~4% | | treasure | ~3% | | library | ~3% | | puzzle | ~1 per 7 floors | **GAME_BRIEFING.md §Spire & Floor System** says: | Room Type | Chance | |-----------|--------| | **Guardian** | Every 10th floor | | **Puzzle** | 20% on every 7th floor | | **Swarm** | **15%** | | **Speed** | **10%** | | **Combat** | Default | Discrepancies: 1. **Swarm**: spire-climbing-spec says ~12%, GAME_BRIEFING says 15% 2. **Puzzle**: spire-climbing-spec says "1 room per 7th floor" (deterministic), GAME_BRIEFING says "20% on every 7th floor" (probabilistic) 3. spire-climbing-spec has recovery/treasure/library rooms (~10% total) which GAME_BRIEFING doesn't mention at all **Recommendation:** Reconcile room type definitions. The spire-climbing-spec is more detailed and includes non-combat rooms that GAME_BRIEFING omits entirely.

Anexim added the ai:todo label 2026-06-05 02:08:28 +02:00

n8n-gitea was assigned by Anexim

2026-06-05 02:08:28 +02:00

Anexim commented

2026-06-05 13:01:37 +02:00

ultimate truth: spire-climbing-spec is the one that is correct here.
puzzle rooms are 100% chance every 7th floor (except on guardian floors)

ultimate truth: spire-climbing-spec is the one that is correct here. puzzle rooms are 100% chance every 7th floor (except on guardian floors)

Anexim commented

2026-06-05 13:54:32 +02:00

RESOLVED — Updated GAME_BRIEFING.md room type frequencies to match spire-climbing-spec: Swarm ~12% (not 15%), Puzzle 100% on every 7th floor (not 20%), added Recovery/Treasure/Library rooms that were missing.

**RESOLVED** — Updated GAME_BRIEFING.md room type frequencies to match spire-climbing-spec: Swarm ~12% (not 15%), Puzzle 100% on every 7th floor (not 20%), added Recovery/Treasure/Library rooms that were missing.

Anexim closed this issue

2026-06-05 14:30:19 +02:00

Anexim added ai:done and removed ai:todo labels 2026-06-05 14:30:19 +02:00

Anexim commented

2026-06-05 14:30:20 +02:00

✅ RESOLVED — Updated GAME_BRIEFING.md room type frequencies to match spire-climbing-spec: Swarm ~12% (not 15%), Puzzle 100% on every 7th floor (not 20%), added Recovery/Treasure/Library rooms.

Sign in to join this conversation.

1 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: Anexim/Mana-Loop#272