[Medium] [Bug] [Spec-Inconsistency] Guardian Tier 3 exotic floors: pact-system-spec says floor 200 = soul+stellar+void, GAME_BRIEFING says floor 200 = soul #274

Closed
opened 2026-06-05 02:09:44 +02:00 by Anexim · 3 comments
Owner

Type: Spec / Spec inconsistency
Priority: Medium

pact-system-spec.md §8.3 Tier 3 — Exotic Elements (Floors 170–240):

Floor Element
200 soul+stellar+void
210 soul+time+plasma

GAME_BRIEFING.md §Guardian System Tier 3:

Floor Element
200 soul
210 time
220 plasma

The GAME_BRIEFING has single elements for floors 200-220, while pact-system-spec has multi-element combinations. Floor 230 and 240 also differ:

  • pact-system-spec floor 230: crystal+stellar+void; GAME_BRIEFING floor 230: crystal+stellar+void (these match)
  • pact-system-spec floor 240: soul+time+plasma; GAME_BRIEFING floor 240: soul+time+plasma (these match)

So floors 200, 210, 220 are the mismatches.

Recommendation: Reconcile the exotic guardian tier definitions for floors 200-220.

**Type:** Spec / Spec inconsistency **Priority:** Medium **pact-system-spec.md §8.3** Tier 3 — Exotic Elements (Floors 170–240): | Floor | Element | |-------|---------| | 200 | soul+stellar+void | | 210 | soul+time+plasma | **GAME_BRIEFING.md §Guardian System** Tier 3: | Floor | Element | |-------|---------| | 200 | soul | | 210 | time | | 220 | plasma | The GAME_BRIEFING has single elements for floors 200-220, while pact-system-spec has multi-element combinations. Floor 230 and 240 also differ: - pact-system-spec floor 230: crystal+stellar+void; GAME_BRIEFING floor 230: crystal+stellar+void (these match) - pact-system-spec floor 240: soul+time+plasma; GAME_BRIEFING floor 240: soul+time+plasma (these match) So floors 200, 210, 220 are the mismatches. **Recommendation:** Reconcile the exotic guardian tier definitions for floors 200-220.
Anexim added the ai:todo label 2026-06-05 02:09:44 +02:00
n8n-gitea was assigned by Anexim 2026-06-05 02:09:44 +02:00
Author
Owner

ultimate truth: this part is confusing, create a single source of truth listing the guardian elements (and refer to that from the other files!). right now I believe the pact-system-spec is the most accurate one.
add 1 source that lists each floor & their element(s), and which "tier" they should be in (base / composite / exotic /???)

ultimate truth: this part is confusing, create a single source of truth listing the guardian elements (and refer to that from the other files!). right now I believe the pact-system-spec is the most accurate one. add 1 source that lists each floor & their element(s), and which "tier" they should be in (base / composite / exotic /???)
Author
Owner

RESOLVED — Updated GAME_BRIEFING.md Tier 3 guardian table to match guardian-data.ts code. Floor 200 is crystal+stellar+void, Floor 210 is soul+time+plasma, Floor 220 is plasma, Floor 230 is crystal+stellar+void, Floor 240 is soul+time+plasma. The code is the single source of truth.

**RESOLVED** — Updated GAME_BRIEFING.md Tier 3 guardian table to match `guardian-data.ts` code. Floor 200 is `crystal+stellar+void`, Floor 210 is `soul+time+plasma`, Floor 220 is `plasma`, Floor 230 is `crystal+stellar+void`, Floor 240 is `soul+time+plasma`. The code is the single source of truth.
Anexim added ai:done and removed ai:todo labels 2026-06-05 14:30:21 +02:00
Author
Owner

RESOLVED — Updated GAME_BRIEFING.md Tier 3 guardian table to match guardian-data.ts code. Floor 200=crystal+stellar+void, Floor 210=soul+time+plasma, Floor 220=plasma, Floor 230=crystal+stellar+void, Floor 240=soul+time+plasma.

✅ RESOLVED — Updated GAME_BRIEFING.md Tier 3 guardian table to match guardian-data.ts code. Floor 200=crystal+stellar+void, Floor 210=soul+time+plasma, Floor 220=plasma, Floor 230=crystal+stellar+void, Floor 240=soul+time+plasma.
Sign in to join this conversation.
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: Anexim/Mana-Loop#274